If you’re looking for a cute way to let someone know how much you love them this year, peruse the collection at Paper Source. Don’t be fooled by its name—this shop is about more than just cards and stationery. While it does have an impressive selection of both (including great options for the holiday), it’s also home to a collection of sweet and silly gifts for significant others and friends alike.

Stock up on treats like heart-shaped candies, a romantic candle, and a customizable book that’s ready and waiting for you to fill in your love story. Round out your hand-picked gift basket with a card featuring the perfect pun—maybe one depicting a herd of kitties declaring “I have felines for you” or one showcasing a bubbly pot of cheese and the words “I’m so glad I fondue.” If you’re in the market for something a little bit more heartfelt, buy a set of cards that simply bear the phrase “I love you because…” at the top with ample space to write a personalized love note on the bottom. Paper Source also has all of the wrapping paper and gift bags you need in order to beautify your chosen presents.